Detroit Lions’ 2025 NFL Draft: Bold moves and controversial picks that could raise eyebrows

The Detroit Lions' 2025 NFL Draft class has been nothing short of polarizing. While some fans and analysts celebrate the team's efforts to address key positions like the offensive and defensive lines, others are questioning whether the Lions took unnecessary risks with certain picks. From reaching for players to controversial trades, the 2025 draft has sparked a fierce debate over the team's strategy. But could these bold moves actually pay off, or did the Lions overplay their hand?


On the surface, the Lions’ draft seems like a step in the right direction. They fortified their lines, added depth, and seemingly filled positions of need. However, as the dust settles, critics have emerged, pointing out several questionable decisions. According to a consensus of 24 NFL draft grades compiled by Rene Bugner, Detroit earned the second-lowest grade, just ahead of the Miami Dolphins and Cincinnati Bengals.
The harshest criticism came from Thor Nystrom of Fantasy Life, who delivered an “F” grade to the Lions. This wasn’t an isolated opinion. Austin Mock from The Athletic also gave Detroit a failing grade, pointing out the risks the team took with their trades and picks. The Lions lost significant draft value in their trade to move up for wide receiver Isaac TeSlaa, who many believe may not have been worth the cost.

Perhaps the most glaring concern was the Lions' decision to wait until the sixth round to address their edge rusher needs. Detroit's defense has struggled with generating consistent pressure on quarterbacks, and with several promising edge rushers available, the team's late-round selection raised eyebrows. In a draft deep with talent at the position, skipping this critical need early on is a move that has left fans wondering if the Lions missed out on an opportunity to strengthen their defense.
Despite the mixed reactions, it’s difficult to ignore the success that general manager Brad Holmes has had since taking over in 2021. Holmes has consistently hit on draft picks that have developed into key contributors, many of whom are now receiving lucrative second contracts. His ability to find talent is undeniable, and this is why many are reluctant to write off the 2025 draft class completely.
Also Read: Sherrone Moore’s suspension smells of strategic damage control
While the picks made in 2025 may seem risky in hindsight, Brad Holmes' track record in the draft gives him the benefit of the doubt. In the end, the Lions' gamble may turn out to be a brilliant strategy or a costly misstep.